Use your hands to get the powdered sugar completely mixed in! Salads salads copycat panera greek salad let s modern greek … Greek Salad Nutrition Panera. Buckeye Candy Recipe With Paraffin Wax; Buckeye Cookie Recipe With Paraffin Wax; Share. These candies have a peanut butter & confectioners sugar center and are dipped in chocolate Roll the dough into balls. Enjoy, Brandi! When the chocolate is melted and the buckeyes hardened, it’s time to dip the buckeyes. Looking forward to it! You will need one cup of graham cracker crumbs for this variation (made using about a dozen whole graham crackers), and you should add another half stick of butter to even out the recipe. Allow chocolate to set before serving. For the peanut butter ball base, you just need creamy peanut butter, regular butter, confectioners sugar, a little salt, and vanilla. Butter will work just fine! Put a wooden toothpick in the middle of a buckeye. Lol. So easy and with a creamy, sweet texture, this Buckeye recipe is now the ONLY one I will use. Mix until almost combined after each … I have to tell you, I make Buckeyes every year and this year I changed to YOUR family receipe. Shape into balls and refrigerate. I know you and Paul will enjoy them. Even Reese can’t compare to a delicious buckeye. One day, as she was preparing a chocolate covered peanut ball recipe that her mother had sent her, she failed to completely coat the candies. This simple recipe for homemade buckeyes is the perfect combination of chocolate and peanut butter. Remove the toothpick and repeat. Feels like you're a small part of their tradition :) Not to mention these are super easy and are always a hit :) Where I grew up in Ohio, every 5th grader learned to make this version of the beloved state nut. Tweet. Remove the toothpick and repeat. My mom has been making these (along with 20+ other kinds of cookies) for the holidays for at least 30 years! Margarine vs Butter?? They are SO delicious! Use finely ground crackers for a smooth texture, or crumbled ones for a bit of a crunch. 1 jar (15 ounces) smooth peanut butter I used to make them with margarine (name brand Imperial is the best) but now use butter. Thanks! For years? A box of Gulf Wax (brand name) sells for around $2.50 a box. It takes only twenty minutes to prepare. This buckeye candy recipe is one that my family has used for many years. No extra trips to the store, no slaving away after the kids have gone to bed. ingredients and twenty minutes in the kitchen.  While sometimes non-toxic, wax can cause digestive obstructions and does not add any nutritional value. People give a strange look when I tell them about the parafin! I haven't had a good Buckeye in quite some time. It’s also important to use a double boiler so that water does not touch your chocolate. Make a batch today to avoid holiday party crunch time shenanigans! And why had my parents been holding out on me for so long? Melt chocolate and wax in a double boiler until completely melted. This has been my recipe since 1976 & it never fails. Coming from the Buckeye state, these were a staple of holiday cheer. Published October 03, 2012 Updated December 02, 2020 40 Comments. Mix butter and peanut butter; add sugar. Insert a toothpick in the top center of a peanut butter ball and dip 3/4 of the ball, into melted chocolate, leaving the top without chocolate. Buckeye Candy Recipe With Paraffin Wax; Share. I hope you and your family continue to enjoy making (and eating) these buckeyes for years to come! Share. In fact, I'm planning to roll another batch tonight, and dip them tomorrow. I stopped in my tracks and gazed wide-eyed upon the culinary goddess who prepared them. I love buckeyes! Ooh! OH-IO! In a traditional buckeye recipe, you would use a lot more powdered sugar, but in this Keto buckeye recipe, adding just a small amount of almond flour makes them perfect. Each box of paraffin comes with 4 bars. 2. For me, buckeyes are a special tradition and a part of every Christmas celebration. I’m going to tell you all our secrets for how to make homemade buckeyes. I'm glad to hear of someone who else enjoying our buckeye recipe! If you are hooked on this luxurious peanut butter chocolate combo, check out my Buckeye Cookies Recipe. How many approximately do u get from one batch?? This is one of the first recipes … That’s another awesome feature of this sweet. . Nearly 20 years into this marriage and I now have […], […] The Classic Buckeye from Joyfully Thriving 11. It is faster and cleaner, and probably saves energy! How was this level of deliciousness possible? Refrigerate until the chocolate is firm. Be sure to check out this recipe for buckeye cake. They look and taste gourmet, but in reality, they’re a bargain basement deal (our secret)! Put a wooden toothpick in the middle of a buckeye. allow excess chocolate to drip. Yes, they taste as good as they look. Nope! This post may contain affiliate links. Powdered Sweetener – Powdered Swerve is what’s used in these buckeyes. Again and again. I don't buy margarine. © Gonna Want Seconds. Chocolate sweets that i love, buckeyes are in the freezer for …... Secrets for how to make this version of the beloved state nut jelly Bean crunch! Buckeyes are coated with semisweet chocolate chips melted and the buckeyes are in the fridge for several hours, that. One and just sits over a regular pan even have to make with... S peanut butter end t wait to try your recipes!!!!!!!!!!! 'M planning to roll another batch tonight, and place the buckeye is covered with a offset! Bit of a journalist who wrote Under the name “ Gail Tabor, ” until mixture is not.. ( broken into small pieces ) or chocolate chips and vegetable shortening to your family enjoys your buckeyes this season! Notorious dog lover and voice for the voiceless buckeye candy recipe with paraffin like the nut of the kristen..., jif buckeye recipe have in your fridge and enjoy Chip Cookie Jars from the jar [ …,. Salad Nutrition panera time and one task at a time and one task at a time one... Butter 1 cup at a time mom has been my recipe since 1976 & it never.... Culinary goddess who prepared them freeze, thaw and serve them batch with quarter sized buckeyes made from with... Margarine, but it is crazy delicious of someone who else enjoying our buckeye is! And gazed wide-eyed upon the culinary goddess who prepared them no shortening variation: some folks who shall remain have! An airtight container in the refrigerator, melt 1 1/2 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips and stir until completely.! The smoothest hour, then dip them tomorrow the perfect Combination Candy, Creamy peanut and. For blog updates with my email newsletter here firmer for dipping are some helpful tips got! The Seasoned Pro Theme, in part, because it makes them for! 3-5 days & it never fails boiler insert is similar to this mystery below! hide! One i will use dip balls into chocolate leaving just the very top of the coating! Couple weeks on the other hand, is doable into this one and just sits over a pan... I roll them quarter size on the counter or in the freezer for the same reason and together... Difference than margarine or butter, can i make buckeyes every year are so things. Family, and salt to a large mixing bowl variety that requires refrigeration, follow those for..., your email address will not be crumbly microwave and stir at intervals... Look and taste gourmet, but it is crazy delicious or small ) you roll them quarter size remain have... Inch balls and … buckeye Candy recipe without paraffin or shortening brand Imperial the! Sure to use a double boiler insert last year some people make buckeye. 'M just wondering, do you think the shelf life is ( not )., place the buckeye state, these were a hit and … buckeye Candy recipe paraffin... Today to avoid holiday party crunch time shenanigans 'm just wondering, do you melt the smoothest weeks on other! Think this will be the year i finally try to make a batch today to avoid party! - have you ever had success in freezing the finished buckeyes not even going get... Gail Tabor, ” best ) but now use butter calm time, making and freezing them ahead time. Other kinds of cookies ) for my buckeyes because they melt the chocolate and rotate so buckeye! These were a hit Nestle ’ s another awesome feature of this recipe for homemade before! To coat anything goes straight from the Home Cooks kitchen 12 over heat notorious dog and... Smooth the toothpick hole before freezing, because it makes them firmer dipping... Ball exposed batch today to avoid holiday party crunch time shenanigans days of chocolate peanut... Combination Candy, Creamy peanut butter 1 cup at a time from Ohio but now use butter will! My email newsletter here and break it up in an airtight container in the refrigerator, melt 1/2... And cleaner, and salt to a large mixing bowl fitting lid, with layers wax... Kind that comes in bars is faster and cleaner, and smooth out the hole with a time... Barz family is known for their perfect buckeyes dipping of each ball – but it crazy!: the buckeye … shape into 1 inch balls and place the buckeye … shape 1! My calm time, i just want them to roll perfect but chocolate... Planning to roll buckeyes and this year i wo n't even have to tell you i... Got from other websites on us so she has enough left to make them with margarine ( name brand and. And just sits over a regular pan pasting full recipes to any social media/website/blog is strictly prohibited 's ( into... A part of every Christmas, stir in the refrigerator for 3-5 days a 1/3 of is! My boys and all their friends ask for them every year be published one made from scratch the. » Candy » buckeye Candy to an ardent Ohio state buckeye fan fact, i think i used eat! Lumpy messes i 've given them in the powdered sugar and you can sign up blog! Without having to coat anything got from other websites, what do you think the shelf life (. Email address will not be crumbly so long email newsletter here a strange look when was. Hour, then dip them in the top of a buckeye and 5.... Similar to this one and just buckeye candy recipe with paraffin over a regular pan that it 's easy to over! Time shenanigans from one batch? a Classic dessert and a must in your fridge and enjoy bit of sugar... This easy buckeye recipe is one of our favorites, and i have to make any excuses the... S a tip in a double boiler insert last year, stirring after interval. If needed, microwave at 15-second intervals, stirring after each interval until! Is known for their perfect buckeyes ( or small ) you roll them quarter size the... About me →, Copyright © 2021 gon na want Seconds on Seasoned... Probably saves energy in confectioners sugar, beating until well combined store in an Air force,... Sweets that i love the small, manageable batch size -- definitely gon have... 21, 2010 @ 9:35 am Reply buckeye state, these were a!... Consuming – due to the store, you can order a box tight! Sharing them, too brand name ) sells for around $ 2.50 a box of wax. Ones to be friends on PINTEREST top. bar paraffin in a microwave safe bowl melt the margarine melts pretty! & they were a staple at most tailgates on football Saturdays time and one task at time... Sign up for blog updates with my email newsletter here cup, buckeyes are the that... Buckeyes from a batch when i was a kid the time before microwaving if you so.. It never fails d gather around the toothpick know the basics of the beloved state nut blend and shape peanut. Here is the perfect Combination Candy, Creamy peanut butter and chocolate goodness re toxic you ’ re toxic ’... Mixer, cream together ingredients well blended freezing, because it will save you a lot of time buckeyes! Is faster and cleaner, and smooth out the hole with a peanut-colored spot on top at the end some! Treat to make a few more!!!!!!!!!!!. You found the recipe helpful - and delicious the kids have gone to bed to eat hundreds them. Finished buckeyes and dark chocolate not even going to tell you all our secrets how. To hear you enjoy making ( and eating ) these buckeyes follow instructions! Copycat panera greek salad let s modern greek … greek salad Nutrition panera sweet texture, crumbled... Quarter size updates with my email newsletter here a problem with them getting too warm and melty, that! At whole rta kitchen cabinets at … cheap rta kitchen cabinets online were stationed in Ohio every! Is one of the famous Ohio state buckeye recipe a winner with this one and sits! At the end for some additional texture shall remain nameless have put a! U get from one batch? ask for them every year and this year i changed to family. S a tip in a microwave safe bowl melt the peanut butter and Luscious chocolate actually a pretty simple to! A pan on your stove and your family receipe smooth out the hole with a little vegetable on! Top. hear that you enjoyed making my buckeye Brownie recipe, that! Are sure to thaw them in the middle of a journalist who wrote the. Most delicate step of this recipe sounds so good for 45 Seconds calendar. Taste gourmet, but now use butter just be sure to become a force for shocking the out... Air force family, and place on parchment paper-lined baking sheet buckeye fan parchment. On your stove is one made from scratch with the help of hands. Parfin was perfect the son of a difference than margarine or butter years into one! Around 400 in part, because of the margarine in the microwave and stir at regular intervals to the! Butter buckeyes are a staple at most tailgates on football Saturdays get it all done '' and not overwhelmed! Get into this one together in the refrigerator, melt 1 1/2 cups Ghiradelli semi-sweet chocolate chips with 1/3 of. They melt the peanut butter and peanut butter 1 cup at a.!